You saw an ad for Amish puppies, or a friend warned you about Amish puppy mills, and now you want the truth before you hand over a deposit. Here it is in plain terms. Commercial dog breeding is a real business in several areas with large Amish and Plain populations, including Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, Holmes County, Ohio, and northern Indiana. Some of those kennels have long inspection records with violations. Others pass their inspections. Not every Amish breeder runs a puppy mill, and no agency tracks breeders by religion.
So the better question is: how are these dogs living, and can I see it? Below is what public records show, why problems cluster where they do, and how to check any breeder before you buy.
What the records show
The best-known public tally is the Horrible Hundred, an annual report from Humane World for Animals (formerly the Humane Society of the United States). It draws on state, federal and court records and lists only dealers with documented violations or concerns in the prior 12 months. It is not a list of every puppy mill, since many breeders are never inspected.
In the 2026 report, Missouri had the most dealers for the 14th year in a row, with 31. Wisconsin followed with 14, then New York and Pennsylvania with nine each, and Kansas and Ohio with eight each. Most kennels in the report are state or federally licensed.
The report does not label breeders by faith, and neither do we. It does show a cluster in Plain farming country. The 2026 report lists kennels in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, and notes that one operation advertised on the Lancaster Puppies website, “a site that Humane World has repeatedly linked to puppy mills.” In 2023, four of Pennsylvania’s eight listed kennels were in Lancaster County.
In 2017, Snopes cited state records showing 134 of Ohio’s 268 licensed breeding facilities were in Holmes County, and 119 known commercial kennels in Lancaster County. It also rated a viral claim that the Amish own 20% of puppy mills “not verifiable,” because states do not record breeders’ religion.
Why commercial breeding grows in farm country
In parts of farm country, commercial dog breeding is often run like other livestock work. Humane officers in Lancaster County told PennLive that some Amish breeders view their dogs as livestock even though the puppies are sold as pets. In Indiana, Purdue University’s Center for Animal Welfare Science began working in 2016 with Amish and non-Amish commercial breeders on voluntary standards for more socialization and exercise. Practices differ from kennel to kennel.
Oversight is the other half of the story. The U.S. Department of Agriculture licenses breeders under the federal Animal Welfare Act only when they have five or more breeding females and sell puppies sight unseen, to pet stores, brokers or online buyers. A breeder who sells only in person does not need a USDA license, even with hundreds of dogs. Humane World calls the federal standards “minimal” and says the agency rarely revokes licenses. The ASPCA adds that a USDA license is “no guarantee of better care.”
States fill the gap unevenly. Pennsylvania’s 2008 dog law, signed by Gov. Ed Rendell, required larger cages, no wire flooring, outdoor access, no stacked cages and veterinary checks twice a year. The Associated Press reported in 2010 that commercial kennels in the state fell from 303 to 111 as many operators closed rather than comply. By 2012, a state advisory board said enforcement had slipped so far that kennel owners could “evade the legal kennel requirements with virtual impunity.” Ohio began licensing high-volume breeders, those who sell 60 dogs a year and breed at least nine litters, in 2014.
What life is like inside a documented mill
Kennels differ, so here is what records in the 2026 Horrible Hundred say about specific ones:
- In Pennsylvania, authorities reported Chester View Kennel for suspected cruelty after the breeder used tight rubber bands to dock puppies’ tails.
- At Happy Canine Kennel in Wisconsin, a dog’s eye injury was so severe the eye had to be removed.
- An inspector at Bow Wow Mound Kennels in Kansas, which sold to Petland, had to leave the building because the odor burned their eyes, nose and throat.
- USDA found three-week-old puppies had been transported by one dealer, warning that moving underage puppies “could cause them to become sick and even die.”
The report also describes underweight mother dogs, frozen water in winter, and dogs bred litter after litter.
How the puppies reach buyers
Few buyers ever see these kennels. Puppies move through:
- Online listings. Humane World says many breeders in its report sell through social media and sites such as Puppies.com, GreenfieldPuppies.com and LancasterPuppies.com, to families who never meet the puppy first.
- Pet stores. Petland is the only national chain still selling puppies, and more than 20 of the 2026 Horrible Hundred breeders have sold to it.
- Brokers. Middlemen resell litters from many kennels, which hides where a puppy was born.
- Dog auctions. Breeding dogs are bought and sold at auctions such as Southwest Auction Service in Wheaton, Missouri, which dvm360 described in 2018 as the largest legal dog auction in the country, with a strong Amish presence among buyers. Cincinnati CityBeat reported in 2012 that Ohio’s Farmerstown auction drew dogs from as far as Minnesota.
How to check any breeder before you buy
Use this list for every breeder. For more detail, read our guide, Puppy Mill vs Breeder: How to Tell the Difference.
- Visit in person. Ask to meet the mother, and the father if he is on site, and to see where all the dogs live, not just a clean front room. The ASPCA calls refusal a “huge red flag.”
- Look up the USDA record. If the breeder ships puppies or sells online, search their name in the USDA Animal Care Public Search Tool. You can read their inspection reports and see any noncompliant items.
- Check the state license. In Pennsylvania, ask for the kennel license number and confirm it with the Department of Agriculture’s Bureau of Dog Law Enforcement. Ohio licenses high-volume breeders through its Department of Agriculture.
- Do not trust papers alone. The ASPCA notes that registries such as the AKC do not inspect kennels or verify a puppy’s health.
- Watch for red flags. A breeder who will not let you visit, offers only shipping or a meet-up away from the kennel, or cannot give you a license number while selling online. The ASPCA also warns that online puppy photos can be copied from other sites.
If you already bought a sick puppy you think came from a mill, Humane World says you can report it to the USDA and to humaneworld.org/puppycomplaint.
What we do, and how you can help

Wounded Paw Project rescues dogs from abuse and neglect, including dogs who spent years in breeding kennels. Our rescue dog rehabilitation program gives them medical care, time and patience until they are ready for a home. You can read where some of them ended up on our success stories page, and learn more about puppy mills.
- Adopt. Every adopted dog is one less sale for a kennel that cuts corners.
- Report. If you see dogs living in neglect, call our anonymous Animal Abuse Hotline at (844) 728-2729.
- Give. Your gift pays for vet care, food and recovery time for rescued dogs. Donate to Wounded Paw Project.
Frequently asked questions
Are all Amish breeders puppy mills? No. Some Amish-run kennels have records of violations, and others pass their inspections. No agency tracks breeders by religion, so judge each kennel by its own records and conditions.
Is it safe to buy a puppy from an Amish breeder? It can be, if you check the kennel like any other. Visit, meet the mother, see where the dogs live, and read the USDA and state inspection reports. If the breeder will not let you visit, walk away.
Which states have the most puppy mills? In the 2026 Horrible Hundred report, Missouri had the most problem dealers for the 14th year in a row, followed by Wisconsin, New York, Pennsylvania, Kansas and Ohio. Higher counts can also reflect states that inspect more.
How do I check a breeder’s USDA record? Go to the USDA Animal Care Public Search Tool, search the breeder’s name or license number, and open their inspection reports. Breeders who only sell in person do not need a USDA license, so also check the state kennel license.
Where do Amish puppies sold online come from? Often from commercial kennels selling through puppy websites, brokers or pet stores. Humane World has linked LancasterPuppies.com to puppy mills, so ask for the breeder’s name and license before you pay.